"The Jewish Hymn: Onward Christian Soldiers"

In 1940, an overwhelming majority of Americans believed World War II believed that the United States should not become in the conflict. Advocates of isolationism, such as the America First Committee, made a variety of arguments as to why the US should not join France and the UK to fight Nazi Germany. The featured poster highlights how some of those opposed to US involvement in the war used antisemitic theories to justify their position.

Produced by a writer named Robert Edward Edmondson, this document accused American Jews of using their supposed control of the media and the global economy for sinister purposes.¹ Such conspiracy theories drew on previous expressions of global antisemitism, and were pushed by other prominent figures, such as Father Charles E. Coughlin and Henry Ford.² Like Coughlin and Ford, Edmondson falsely claimed that there was an international conspiracy to bring about war that was supposedly being waged by Jews in media, finance, and government. "The American people have no quarrel with Germany or Japan," Edmondson writes. "The only people who want war are—THE JEWS!"

Edmondson also claimed that Nazi policies against Jews and other minorities were consistent with American history and values, and that Nazi race laws were not really much different from those in the United States. At a time when some US laws reflected racist attitudes,³ Edmondson encouraged Americans to see the Nazi racial state not as an enemy but as something familiar—and admirable.⁴

Edmundson and several others accused of promoting isolationist and pro-fascist views were indicted by the US Department of Justice and faced trial for sedition in 1944.

For more on antisemitic myths and stereotypes in the United States, see the related items "The International Jew: The World's Foremost Problem" and the "The Truth About Revolution."

In the 1930s, so-called "Jim Crow" laws legalized discrimination aimed at Black and other non-white peoples in most areas of American life. Black Americans were barred from many public places, including hotels, restaurants, and other facilities. In the South especially, non-white people lived in fear of racially motivated violence. Until 1948, the armed forces of the United States remained segregated by race. With the exception of boxing, both college and professional sports were segregated, and equal training opportunities for Black athletes were extremely limited. For more information, see the related collection Black Americans and World War II and the Jim Crow Museum website.

For more on the similarities and differences between legalized racism in Nazi Germany and the United States, see James Q. Whitman, Hitler's American Model: The United States and the Making of Nazi Race Law (Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press, 2017).

All 19 Items in the Nazi Ideals and American Society Collection

Archival Information for This Item